A relative of Colonel DF (‘Nick’) Neill sent me this photograph of his grave in St. Andrews church in South Tawton, Devon.  He commented ‘Their house was next to the church and was called Whytbank after the house in which Margaret and Nick may have had their wedding reception in (I think it was called Whytbank Castle)’.

In early 2023 Johnny Fenn walked across Nepal from West to East, a distance of about 1400 miles.  It took him 114 days.  His intention was to raise money for a school in Oyam, in eastern Nepal, and the Gurkha Welfare Trust, to each of which he eventually donated about £25,000.  It was a remarkable achievement which he describes in his book ‘The Nepali Way’.

Johnny, a QOGLR officer, retired from the Army in 2012 after two years as the Field Director of the Gurkha Welfare Trust, re-enlisting and resuming the same role in 2024 after twelve years as a freelance photographer.  His account is therefore accompanied by many excellent, full-page photographs.  Even allowing for the naturally photogenic environment of Nepal he took some remarkable shots, particularly of people, using both colour and black and white photographs to very good effect.  He has also avoided the common trap of taking too many pictures of the awe-inspiring scenery.  (I remember many years ago showing Stuart Sessions my photographs from a trek I had just been on, and his remark after a couple of minutes of ‘Oh God, not another f***ing mountain!’).

Knowing the uncertain quality of meat and alcohol in rural Nepal, Johnny sensibly decided to do without both on his trek, even though loss of the former left him short of protein and needing to eat copious quantities of eggs – at one point he was eating a dozen eggs every two days.  His staple diet of dal-bhat did not help either.  He lost nearly 17 kilograms in weight during the trek but avoided major illness or injury apart from one episode where he became seriously dehydrated and had to be plied with saline and glucose drips.  Fortunately he was at that point staying at the Area Welfare Centre at Resunga, where the medical orderly was able to revive him.

He also decided to do without a map, reasoning that asking local people the way would enable him to find the best routes from place to place as well as linking him more closely to the communities he encountered.  If the remarkable photographs are anything to go by this strategy seems to have worked, as they are predominantly of people and have an empathetic quality which lifts them head and shoulders above the kind of selfies or snapshots that someone like me would take.  To my mind the beauty and value of this book lies in these pictures.  While his written account of his trek is interesting in places he is a talented photographer, not a gifted writer, and the photos tell the story far more eloquently than the text.

However, the photographs represent only a fraction of his experiences on the trek.  The vast majority of his time was spent plodding for hours day in, day out, uphill and down dale, which is difficult to convey in prose without giving the impression of grinding monotony.  To avoid this most of the written account describes the communities where they stopped to eat and sleep and the people they met.  He comments in several places that the trek gave him ample time to think about what the future might hold, but I did not get the impression that the trek was an epiphany: he seemed pretty much the same good-natured and enthusiastic chap at the end of it as he was at the beginning, albeit 17kg lighter.  Having said that, in 2024 he returned to his old job in the Army after a break of 12 years out of uniform, so perhaps the trek persuaded him that was a better option than freelance photography.

His account includes numerous observations about the different environments he encountered but these do not amount to a social or cultural survey – nor, quite clearly, is this the intention of the book.  He notes signs of Buddhism and Hinduism in various places, the variety of weather and light at different altitudes and in different terrain, the friendliness or stand-offishness in the places he visits, and he makes a few comments about different building styles.  While not offering any deep analysis his descriptions convey very well the extraordinary variety of Nepal’s geography, climate, cultures and people, not to mention his great affection for all of these things.

I found his picture of the kit he took with him one of the most intriguing (but perhaps least attractive) photos in the book.  It is remarkable how little you need to survive for 16 weeks, and the important part technology now plays compared with treks in the 1980s or even 1990s.  Besides clothing he had a camera (a Nikon Z7 and 24-120 f4 lens, for those interested in such things), a small GPS tracker so friends and family could follow his progress, and an Inmarsat satellite phone for emergencies – and, if I have interpreted his account correctly, for some essential admin.  He also had a small laptop to back up his photos and do email when wifi connectivity was available, and a couple of power banks to recharge his devices when there was no mains power.  Amazingly, all the technology seems to have worked reliably throughout his trek.

In summary, this book as an excellent collection of remarkable photographs of Nepal and its people.  The accompanying text is interesting but by no means a travelogue that could stand on its own merits.  Nevertheless, these two components together offer an evocative, affectionate and attractive record of an extraordinary journey, and I take my hat off to Johnny Fenn for accomplishing it.

NJHH

 

Brigadier John Brewer recently came across this photograph, taken in 1984 in Hong Kong, of British Officers of the 2nd Battalion modelling the various orders of dress they wore then.

Officers’ names, left to right:

Nick Cochrane-Dyet, QM Bob Cox, Sandy McNeil, Commandant John Brewer.  Standing: Richard Coleman, Sean Crane, Harry Duncan, Ollie Blount, Iain Rae, Director of Music Rodney Parker, Ross Forman, Ian Rigden.  Front row: Al Kennedy, John Hare, Peter Scott-Bowden and Tony Bergin.

Brigadier Ian Rigden also found this similar photograph of 2nd Battalion officers in Brunei in 1990:

Standing rear row left to right: mess orderly Harkabahadur, Frazer Lawrence, Sebastian Bather, Mark Mullens (SSLC), RMO John Navein, Assistant Adjutant  Nicola Skentleberry, Sean Crane, Unit Education Officer Graeme Olley, Ian Rigden, Richard Coleman, Operations Officer Nigel Denison (Green Howards), Paymaster Rick Dunn, Phil Lewis (Duke of Wellington’s Regiment), QM Maj (GCO) Milan Gurung QGE, James Coulson.

Front Row left to right: Simon Clements, William Gittus, Chris Kendall (1st Battalion and an instructor at TTB), Commandant Christopher Lavender, Dan Huntingdon and Officers’ Mess Dog.

In 2021 the then Trustees of the 2GR Trust approved a grant of £2,000 to the Gurkha Museum to fund an annual lecture, to be delivered by a speaker of note, foremost to mark the remarkable contribution Denis Wood made to both Regimental and Brigade heritage during a lifetime of service, and also to support the Gurkha Museum’s fundraising programme.

The inaugural “Wood Lecture” took place on Friday 18th September in the Museum’s MacDonald Gallery.  It was presented by Lieutenant General Sir Peter Duffell to a full house of Museum, Brigade and Regimental supporters.  Denis, who had sadly died earlier in the year, was represented by his daughter Carolyn.

Against the backcloth of the 60th anniversary of the Borneo Confrontation Peter’s chosen subject was: “Borneo – The Secret War.”  It was particularly appropriate as it was a campaign in which Colonel Denis Wood had served three six-month operational tours as Second-in-Command of the 1st Battalion.

It was a discourse of the highest quality, best summed up by the Museum’s Chair of Trustees in his closing comments: “I do not think anyone else today could give such a talk that effortlessly moved between the geo-politics of Confrontation and your own experiences of a highly successful and decorated company commander operating “over the border” on Op CLARET.”

The lecture was delivered from the lectern that Denis, with Carolyn, had presented to the Museum in memory of his wife Chris. It was in every sense an occasion entirely befitting the contribution Denis had made to Gurkha heritage during his lifetime.

The Museum intends that the Wood Lecture becomes a long-standing annual series.

Lieutenant General Sir Peter Duffell and Carolyn Wood at the lectern presented by Denis and Carolyn Wood in memory of Chris Wood.

Newsome on the North-West Frontier in 1940.

Captain Maurice Newsome was a 2nd Goorkhas officer who joined the Regiment in 1940. After serving with the 2nd, 3rd and 4th Battalions he was seconded to the newly formed 50th Indian Parachute Brigade, serving as a company commander in 153 and 154 Gurkha Parachute Battalions before taking command of the parachute training school in Delhi. In August 1943 he was killed in a car crash in Murree while returning from an exercise recce, leaving his wife and 4-month old son.

His death certificate and records of the Commonwealth War Graves Commission record his unit and regiment as 3rd Battalion 7th Gurkha Rifles, but he is not recorded in 7GR archives as ever having served with them, nor does his name appear in the 2GR roll of honour or on the brass tablet commemorating officers who died during the Second World War. Other evidence proves conclusively that he was, and remained at the time of his death, an officer of the 2nd Goorkhas.

To read the full story behind this anomaly, including photographs of Maurice Newsome and his family, please click here.

Brigadier Ian Rigden recently came across this photo of the remaining Borneo campaign veterans who were serving in 2/2GR in 1990:

Left to right: Major(QGO) Haribahadur Gurung MVO, Captain(QGO) Guptabahadur Gurung, Captain(QGO) Uttimbahadur Gurung, Captain(QGO) Narbahadur Thapa, Captain(QGO) Bhupalsing Thapa, Captain(QGO) Dhanbahadur Gurung, Captain(QGO) Bhimbahadur Pun, Major(GCO) Kharkabahadur Gurung and Captain(QGO) Lalbahadur Rana.

The machine-gun shown in the picture is now outside the Quarterguard of the Gurkha barracks at Tuker Lines in Brunei.

The Sirmoor Sim Shoot took place at the Kennett Shooting Grounds on Saturday 26th September. It is always planned for this time of the year for guns to get their eyes in before the start of the game shooting season.

The 12 guns were: Bruce Jackman, Julia Bridges (with Richard being a ‘Good Shot Darling’ supporter/loader), Tom Martin, Charles Corbett and his guest Jeremy Stephenson (ex-Royal Hussar), Richard and Penny Firth, Edward and Sarah Mackaness (Sarah’s first shoot), Nigel Blackwell and his son Hugo, and John Swanston.

We met at 0900 at the Barn in The Farm at Avebury for a bacon butty breakfast with tea or coffee before moving out to our first drive at 1100. The shoot was expertly run by Josh Brown from the Barbury Shooting School who is familiar with the Sirmoor guns, having run this shoot for us for the last 8 years! He ensures the day is relaxed and not hurried between drives – which suits our ailing guns perfectly.

We shot over a beautiful part of the Marlborough Downs with rolling hills. We had 5 drives simulating mixed driven game – pheasant and partridge – crossing the gun line at different heights and angles, making shooting very realistic and quite testing. Some guns were adept at ‘poaching’ birds (clays) off the noses of their neighbouring guns, which was all part of the fun.

After two drives we stopped for elevenses of delicious partridge pate of French bread and a glass of Prosecco which we had at the Shooting Hut. Style! Three more drives took us up to a cold meat & salad lunch which we had back at the Farm at Avebury. We had two more drives – the first low and fast ‘partridge’ and the second high ‘pheasant’, followed by a competition between teams of three shooting simulated ‘pigeon’ rising out of kale which was won by Bruce, Penny Firth, and John Swanston. Prize giving and tea ended a thoroughly enjoyable days shoot. Top gun for the day was Julia Bridges who shot quite magnificently – the clays didn’t stand a chance!

So ended the Sirmoor Sim Shoot for 2026. There are mixed feelings about only having one shoot in the year, so we are exploring having a second shoot earlier in the year in 2027. Jai Sirmoor!”

Sir Sidney Burrard Bt KCSI FRS was the Surveyor General of India who played a major role in the Great Trigonometrical Survey of the Himalayas. He was commissioned into the Royal Engineers and joined the Bengal Sappers and Miners.  During his service he lived and worked in Dehra Dun.  In 1887, he married Gertrude Ellen (daughter of Major General C. T. Haig, Superintendent of the Trigonometrical Survey) who was an accomplished amateur artist.  She spent much of her time during their 1890 furlough studying painting. On her return to India, she recorded the people and places she encountered on her travels in the subcontinent.

In 1893, on the suggestion of Major Charles Judge (killed at Dargai in 1897), she painted a portrait of Subedar Major Judhbir Thapa, Bahadur OBI, Subedar Major of the 1st Battalion 2nd Goorkhas (see the painting above).  According to Sir Sidney Burrard, the Subedar Major was not a good sitter unless he was allowed to smoke. When the painting was finished, he apparently complained that his medals had not been given sufficient prominence, to which Judge had to agree.  However, the artist wished to subdue the brightness of the medals because she was more concerned about painting a soldier rather than a group of medals.  The Subedar Major stated that unless his medals were right, nothing else mattered, and under pressure Gertrude Burrard had to change the painting more than she liked.

The painting was exhibited along with 519 others at the Western India Exhibition, at Poona in 1894, and Gertrude Burrard’s portrait of Judhbir Thapa was awarded the highest prize.  On her picture being returned to her , Gertrude Burrard painted a replica, which she gave to Major Judge.   The original was later gifted to the National Army Museum by the artist’s husband, as was the replica in 1967 by Mrs Narayanee Lewis Hall (née Miss Narayanee Judge, daughter of Major and Mrs Judge) who married a son of Brigadier General Lewis Hall of the 2nd Goorkhas.  Another copy was painted by Chater Paul Chater and is in the Gurkha Museum.

Sir John Nott served in the 1st Battalion of the 2nd Goorkhas from 1953-56.  An extract from his 2002 autobiography describing his military service can be downloaded here.

The book also contains an interesting exchange between Nott and Field Marshal Lord Bramall, Colonel of the 2nd Goorkhas, during the planning for the Falklands War, when Nott was Secretary of State for Defence and Bramall was a General and Chief of the General Staff:

Nott: Dwin, you can’t send the Gurkhas. We are having frightful trouble holding things together in the United Nations and it is more than likely that the Indians will kick up a frightful fuss. It is just too risky politically to send the Gurkhas in my view.

Bramall: The 7th Gurkhas are part of 5th Brigade, the designated strategic reserve, and if we recoil from sending them now there will always be some reason for not sending the Gurkhas on future operations.

Nott: I agree that point and, as an ex-Gurkha I would, of course, be mortified if we spoilt their chances.

Bramall: Look, Secretary of State, I am the Colonel of your Regiment [the 2nd Goorkhas] and I am telling you that they must go and I am requiring your support to fight our corner with the Foreign Office.

Nott: If you are instructing me in your capacity as Colonel of the 2nd Goorkhas, then of course, Dwin, I have no option but to obey!

Lieutenant General Sir Peter Duffell recalls:

“I was very familiar with that exchange as I was a Colonel in military operations at the time and the CGS had discussed this issue with me.  I had encouraged him to take the line he did.  Subsequent to his exchange with John Nott and with the FCO still fretting General Dwin, in front of Ministers at a meeting at Chequers, told Mrs Thatcher that he was planning to send a Gurkha Battalion to the Falklands.  ‘Only one?’ came her reply and so all was set.”

Total 302 members: 125 full membership; 103 attached/seconded/relatives; 74 honorary.